About Us

MuncieRentals.com is a property management company providing the best Muncie housing. We have unbeatable locations, and are owned/operated by local BSU graduates. When you deal with MuncieRentals.com, you’re talking with local managers who live and work in Muncie.

MuncieRentals.com is a division of MiddleTown Property Group (MTPG), formerly Network Property Services. At MiddleTown, we are committed to providing the highest level of service to both owners and tenants. No problem is too big or too small. Your happiness is our first priority. 

We’d love the opportunity to find you a home that you can be excited about, besides, it’s a the lease we can do!

Want even more to chirp about?
Here are a few of our features that we pride ourselves on:
• Affordability
• 24-hour maintenance
• Online payments and maintenance requests
• Properties near bus stops
• Free parking
• Most properties with laundry in-unit or on-site
• Majority of properties are pet-friendly
• Reward program in which you have the chance to win gift cards and prizes
• Exclusive discounts at local hot spots through the Door Deals program

Residents, reach out and let us know how we are doing! Property owners, please visit middletownpg.com to learn more about our property management services.

Our Staff

Matt Abner, CEO/President

matt.abner@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618 Ext 203

 

Sarah Ben Zion, Accounting Manager

sarah.benzion@middletownpg.com

 

Julie Thielen, Senior Property Manager
IN Real Estate Brokers License #RB14048065

Julie.Thielen@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618 Ext 206

 

Kacy McEvoy, Senior Property Manager
IN Real Estate Brokers License #RB14050757

Kacy.McEvoy@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618 Ext 210

 

Ashley Pokorny, Property Manager

ashley.pokorny@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618

 

Orion Nothnagel, Property Manager

orion.nothnagel@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618

 

Reese Flowers, Leasing & Marketing Manager
IN Real Estate Brokers License #RB16000939

reese.flowers@middletownpg.com

765-289-7618 Ext 205